Did you honestly see KP ever do anything that made you sit up say “That’s why he went in the first round!”?
I can think of like 3-5 throws his rookie year - primarily against the Raiders and Ravens.
But in two seasons, a QB makes a handful of good throws and the rest are just table stakes for wearing an NFL uniform - you have to start questioning if the original premise was flawed.
Like I know the coordinator was bad. The OL leaked. But really picture the times you said “wow! This kid can play!”
Now do the same with like 2004 Ben R. Looks a bit different, huh?