The only QBs on this list I was able to see with any regularity over their college careers are Corral and Ridder. Neither really did anything that was overly impressive, IMO. But then again, the college QBs I have been impressed with haven't done much in the NFL either. So basically,
Of this list however, I like Desmond Ridder over the rest due to experience, size, mobility, arm strength, accuracy, and winning percentage.
As I posted in at least one other thread I think the Steelers will go with Rudolph(Rude-Dog), a veteran FA, and a rookie draft pick in 2022/23. If it doesn't work out they will 'rinse/repeat' with draft pick, veteran FA(which could be Rudolph at this point), and new rookie. 'Rinse/Repeat' until they get it right. Maybe not every season but every 3rd draft process at least.
In order of 'my' draft choices at QB....
1. Desmond Ridder - reasons listed above. Plus 7/7 traits on Parcell's list.
2. Kenny Pickett - 52 games
experience in college, 62.4% Comp rate on close to 1700 attempts for over 12k yards. 7/7 traits.
3. Matt Corral/Sam Howell - Seems to be better overall offensive weapons than the rest of the list. Size is the main problem for me. Both only 37 games experience.
4. Carson Strong - I love the size, arm strength, accuracy. Strong will need to pass physicals before I would even consider him though.
5. Bailey Zappe/Malik Willis - Transfers without enough snaps to really get a true evaluation on. At least for me.
- - - Updated - - -
My QB eval record stand at the back of the line as well. It's not an easy read or more teams would have better 'luck' at it. Although, if looking for your next franchise QB and you think maybe player A is it, take him at 20. At least you get 5 seasons to figure it out.