Eli Manning is the Riddick Bowe of QB's IMO. As far as his entire body of work, he underachieved. However, Bowe dominated the then-best boxer twice (Holyfield). Eli went against the GOAT twice and won, probably why he will get in.

Of course I can already hear the narrators say the cliche "Great players aren't always great, they're just great when they have to be". The last two Giants SB teams were pretty much that, they were fringe playoff teams who never looked dominant until the playoffs where they caught fire.

I do have to say I was never really impressed with Eli much, but I will say he may be one of the best ever at staying cool in pressure situations