Bryant McFadden on Ed Reed vs Troy Polamalu

[zulater]

Yet Dawkins did make huge game changing plays. Maybe not in a national televised game but he definitely did.

Numbers with no names attached:

Gonna guess without looking.

From left to right. Troy, Ed Reed, Dawkins.

- - - Updated - - -

Yet Dawkins did make huge game changing plays. Maybe not in a national televised game but he definitely did.

Numbers with no names attached:

Gonna guess without looking.

From left to right. Troy, Ed Reed, Dawkins.

[El-Gonzo Jackson]

Yet Dawkins did make huge game changing plays. Maybe not in a national televised game but he definitely did.

Numbers with no names attached:

Yup, good player but not somebody that I really think was HOF type player. IMO, Dawkins is in the class of Dennis Smith, one of the great safeties of the 80's and 90's, but not really somebody that is HOF player. Hall of very good is what its becoming.

[86WARD]

Gonna guess without looking.

From left to right. Troy, Ed Reed, Dawkins.

- - - Updated - - -



Gonna guess without looking.

From left to right. Troy, Ed Reed, Dawkins.

[zulater]

Donnie Shell belongs in the HOF too. 51 ints and 18 fum rec. They didn't individually list tackles, sacks, and forced fumbles during his career. But he was good in all phases of the game. There weren't many safeties that could stop a rumbling Earl Cambell dead in his tracks!

[JimHarbaugh'ssoakedtissue]

Both was awesome players but seen other greats like Reed. Troy was one of a kind and doubt we see another like him.