Kenny Pickett is who I though he was .. Eagles problem now
Array title="tube517 has a reputation beyond repute">
Man... Time flies
"Zeds dead baby, Zeds dead." - Butch
Lol. One of my favorite Roethlisberger GIFs.Originally Posted by tube517
Anyone remember this nod to Mike Wallace?
Array title="Count Steeler has a reputation beyond repute">
Yup. 75-80 yard TD versus the Colts.
Anyone remember this nod to Mike Wallace?
So the modern day Steeler fan has had a franchise QB for 14 years now. So why all the constant complaining in public and on message boards about only getting to 2 SB and winning?
Enjoy it everybody and lets just hope we don't have another 20 year drought like from when Bradshaw retired in 1984.
It's been a heck of a ride.... good and bad! Here's hoping for a few more years out of Ben and another Lombardi or two.
Hard to believe it's been 14 years already.
14 years ago, a legend was drafted. Without him, the Steelers would still be searching for one for the thumb. Recently watched a youtube video about the 2004 draft of QBs, the Eli and Rivers trade followed by Ben's drop out of the top 10. I thought, sure ended up working out for the Steelers, and Ben
should have drafted Shawn Andrews
should have drafted Shawn Andrews
Kenny Pickett is who I though he was .. Eagles problem now
Array title="pczach has a reputation beyond repute">
should have drafted Shawn Andrews
Array title="Lady Steel has a reputation beyond repute">
Because some people are as dumb as a bag of hair.
Drafting Ben was one of the best decisions the Rooneys ever made.
Everyone should be cherishing every minute Ben is on the field.
Been a rabid Steeler fan for over 4o years and have seen some good players, some very good players, and some great players. I have never seen one better than Ben. He may even be better than Terry was, and those who know me know that's not easy for me to say. Thanks Ben, for 14 great years.
AML
Whats funny about Ben is his noggin obviously got bigger....lol
No doubt in my mind that he is better than Terry!
not when the lights are shining their brightest .... no way a knock on Ben but Terry was lights out on the biggest stage
Kenny Pickett is who I though he was .. Eagles problem now
Array title="pczach has a reputation beyond repute">
Terry did play his best in the playoffs, but it makes you wonder why he didn't play better more often and was often horrible. It's as if he didn't care about regular season games
No knock on Terry, but he had the more talented team by a mile in nearly every game he ever played. Life is always a little easier that way.
Kind of the way Emmett Smith gained the most yards behind that great OL, but nobody thinks he's the best RB.
212 career TD passes and 210 career INT isn't the recipe for success on most teams. Luckily, he played on the best team. They won many, many games in spite of Terry for a lot of his career.
Just sayin'
It was great seeing Terry do so well late in his career when he seemed to finally completely understand the game. If only everything had clicked earlier, he would have had a chance to be much higher on the list of great NFL quarterbacks.
Array title="tube517 has a reputation beyond repute">
should have drafted Shawn Andrews
you will find that MOST QBs in that era ( and before ) statistically where not as good as the modern era guys Hell Look at Namath ( Beaver Falls Tiger ) in the HOF and today he would be a 3rd stringer ( or worse ) 50.1 completion percentage 173 TDs and 220 picks ...... today you would be lucky to hold a clip board
Kenny Pickett is who I though he was .. Eagles problem now
not always, in Super Bowl IX against the Vikings Terry went 9/14 for only 96 yards and 1 TD. we won that Super Bowl because of our defense, not Bradshaw...
I think a lot of it has to be the rules back then. It was harder to play QB then. You were allowed to get hit just like any other player, and DB's could karate chop receivers in their heads back then
Array title="Craic has a reputation beyond repute">
Actually, that was a very good game statistically. Terry played fine for what he was asked to do. Using the modern QB rating, that is a 108.0 game, which is very consistent with this 112.8 overall career Superbowl passer rating (which puts him 4th, behind Joe Montana, Jim Plunkett, and Russell Wilson, the last two only going to the SB twice).
On the other hand, Franco Harris rushed for 158 yards on 34 attempts and Rocky Bleier resuhed for 65 yards on 17 attempts (and Bradshaw had another 33 yards on 5 attempts). That game was won because we have a very good running game (even they fumbled three times), a very good defense, and a very good QB that shined when he had to.
if you think 9/14 for only 96 yards and 1 TD pass for a QB is a good game statistically then we'll just have to agree to disagree...
We need to enjoy this while it lasts, we could be the Browns, still searching for a franchise QB. We've been very blessed to have a guy that's won us two championships, taken us to a third, and will be a Future First Ballot Hall of Famer. I'm going to enjoy watching #7 while we've still got him.
"If I could start my life all over again, I would be a professional football player, and you damn well better believe I would be a Pittsburgh Steeler." Jack Lambert, 1990 HoF Introduction.
Array title="pczach has a reputation beyond repute">
I'm not banging your point. The whole point of the post was that Terry played with a much better team around him for almost his entire career than Ben did. Nobody ever had a better surrounding cast. Also, I've always been weary of Terry's regular season play for long stretches. Sometimes I don't think he did everything he could to play better.
Just for the record, here are some TD-INT ratios:
Staubach 153-109 (missed some of his prime years serving his country)
Stabler 194-222
Bob Griese 192-172
Fran Tarkenton 342-266
Bert Jones 124-101
Billy Kilmer 152-146
Jim Hart 209-247
Ken Anderson 197-160
Archie Manning 125-173
It was Terry's first Super Bowl. Ben stunk up the joint in his first Super Bowl as well.....9/21, 2 picks and no TD's. Let's be fair.
That Vikings defense wasn’t any kind of joke either.
Bradshaw also came through in places the defense didn’t. Pretty much why it’s a team game...
Exactly. Defensive guys in the 70's could mug receivers. You didn't start getting gawdy QB numbers until the league changed the PI call to favor the offense. That paved the way for guys like Marino, Montana, Elway into today. Jesus I see guys like Cam Newton and Brady whine about being hit. They NEVER would have survived the 70's. Remember Lambert picking guys up carrying them a few yards and slamming them to the ground. LOL Lambert would be suspended 1/2 the season today.
Impossible to compare between Bradshaw's era and Ben's era for passing #'s. The rule changes and scheme changes just alter the landscape so much.
I think Plimpton wrote about how offensive players called the middle of the field "the pit" and flatly stated you never went into the pit if you could avoid it. Now, AB, Bell, and Ben make a big part of their living in "the pit".
Routes were less developed then than now. Schemes were far simpler and pre-snap motion and disguise was not to the level it is today. Sub-packages to force mismatches were not as prevalent. And on and on.
DWins, point holds - at least for me - no matter how you slice it. Guys from that era that are in the HOF have #'s that look like modern era 3rd stringers.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
