
Originally Posted by
Butch
Ben was 14-1 his rookie year and his only loss was to a cheatriots team that, according to Hines Ward, "was calling out our plays at the line". That year all the credit went to the D not to Ben. His 2nd year he lead us to the Super bowl, but played a very poorly in that game. That being said we would not have been there if it had not been for his passing leading us over many quality opponents. In 43 he could have just as easily been the MVP as well as James Harrision, but instead it was Santonio. He has taken us to 3 and won 2 so on that alone I will put him higher than Rodgers.
I understand why people rate Rodgers so high, and if we didn't have Ben I would want him, but I seriously don't get all the credit given to shady brady. The team cheated so you have to ask just how good would he be on a level playing field. Not only was the cheating with illegal filming of other teams, but also the communications to his helmet would stay on when they should have been cut off. For his cheating I have absolutely no respect for him or his team.