-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
teegre
Trade CONFIRMED
At this point I feel like someone inside the Steelers is just screwing with Dulac.
“And then I told him that we’re trading Fitzpatrick for WR depth…”
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mojouw
At this point I feel like someone inside the Steelers is just screwing with Dulac.
“And then I told him that we’re trading Fitzpatrick for WR depth…”
:lol:
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Just an example trade scenario, I would send Trubisky to LA for Matt Feiler. They make about the same salary and Herbert has 6 foot Chase Daniels as backup. Move Okafor to LT and sit Moore.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Steeler-in-west
Just an example trade scenario, I would send Trubisky to LA for Matt Feiler. They make about the same salary and Herbert has 6 foot Chase Daniels as backup. Move Okafor to LT and sit Moore.
The Taperiots need a receiver… and they were one of the teams “kind of” interested in Rudolph. Isaiah Wynn is in the final year of his contract, and Bill loves trading guys who want new contracts.
That said, the rumor is that Bill is going to live or die with Mac Jones… in hopes of “not tanking” for one of the top-tier QBs in the 2023 draft. So, he might not want another QB, nor a receiver. Then again, that could also mean he’s willing to get rid of any offensive player (Wynn) who doesn’t help them “not tank”.
SUMMATION:
Wynn for our R3 makes sense.
Wynn for Sims, Rudolph, and our R4 would be my preference.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
teegre
The Taperiots need a receiver… and they were one of the teams “kind of” interested in Rudolph. Isaiah Wynn is in the final year of his contract, and Bill loves trading guys who want new contracts.
That said, the rumor is that Bill is going to live or die with Mac Jones… in hopes of “not tanking” for one of the top-tier QBs in the 2023 draft. So, he might not want another QB, nor a receiver. Then again, that could also mean he’s willing to get rid of any offensive player (Wynn) who doesn’t help them “not tank”.
SUMMATION:
Wynn for our R3 makes sense.
Wynn for Sims, Rudolph, and our R4 would be my preference.
Wynn seems undersized for a tackle (6-02). Still might be a better addition than Feiler, who’s 30 and allowed two more sacks. We need O line help more than we need Trubisky or MR added with a wr. to me either guy backing up KP would do. We need an OT first priority…..(maybe we need a new line coach as well eventually)
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Steeler-in-west
Wynn seems undersized for a tackle (6-02). Still might be a better addition than Feiler, who’s 30 and allowed two more sacks. We need O line help more than we need Trubisky or MR added with a wr. to me either guy backing up KP would do. We need an OT first priority…..(maybe we need a new line coach as well eventually)
Undersized or not, Wynn is a better option than what we currently have.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
beachum was undersized too and did well for himself
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
DuckHodges
beachum was undersized too and did well for himself
Re-Cap of this thread:
Wynn at RT
Chukks to LT
Moore to RG (to battle Daniels)
Green cut (seriously… he’s awful)
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
All I know is that right now I'm really disappointed that I came here and Tomlin didn't decide to announce his quarterback selection at 3:30 in the morning Eastern Time like a man.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
teegre
Re-Cap of this thread:
Wynn at RT
Chukks to LT
Moore to RG (to battle Daniels)
Green cut (seriously… he’s awful)
Not enough to make that unit better...
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
86WARD
Not enough to make that unit better...
Chukks is playing better than Moore. Moving Chukks to LT improves that position (even if it’s only slightly better, it is indeed an improvement).
Wynn only has to be equal to Chukks’s play at RT… and Wynn is a pretty good RT. Voila!!! improved O-line.
Moore learning the new hand technique (some former NFL lineman was saying the hand-use that Moore is currently being taught a different technique than Klemm used) for a year behind Wynn affords Moore time to develop. Or… we kick him inside and he battles against Daniels (who was supposed to be an upgrade, but hasn’t look like it thus far).
Lastly, cutting Green allows the Steelers to pick up another free agent… who will be better than Green. I usually don’t give up on a player so quickly, but Green looks completely overwhelmed; any other player would have at least some chance to be better. Because as it us, Green is nothing like the dominant LG that he was in college… and keeps getting worse.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
steelreserve
All I know is that right now I'm really disappointed that I came here and Tomlin didn't decide to announce his quarterback selection at 3:30 in the morning Eastern Time like a man.
Tomlin knows. The team knows. But, unless he absolutely has to announce it, he won’t… because it forces the Bengals to prep for BOTH quarterbacks.
What he should do is announce Rudolph as the starter. Then, some team will be like, “He’s a starter!!!… we will give you two R1 picks for him.” Then, Rudolph gets traded on Sept 9th, we get a pick (actually a R4), and the Bengals have wasted two weeks of planning time.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
steelreserve
All I know is that right now I'm really disappointed that I came here and Tomlin didn't decide to announce his quarterback selection at 3:30 in the morning Eastern Time like a man.
“Get used to disappointment”.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
It seems like the Steelers themselves are the one trying to drum up interest in a Rudolph trade themselves. All these reports that the Steelers received trade interest must be getting leaked out deliberately by a usually tight lipped front office.
I am guessing that so far all they received is the conditional swap of 7th round picks
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
teegre
Tomlin knows. The team knows. But, unless he absolutely has to announce it, he won’t… because it forces the Bengals to prep for BOTH quarterbacks.
What he should do is announce Rudolph as the starter. Then, some team will be like, “He’s a starter!!!… we will give you two R1 picks for him.” Then, Rudolph gets traded on Sept 9th, we get a pick (actually a R4), and the Bengals have wasted two weeks of planning time.
What he should do against the Bengals is announce Joe Burrow as the starter, and then everyone will go, "You can't do that, he's on the other team!!" but he'll be like, "too late, I announced it," and then they'll have to spend the whole week preparing for Burrow and they'll be all pissed off.
Then when the game starts, he says "offense, play defense - defense, play offense," and amazingly, that improves the OL.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
teegre
The Taperiots need a receiver… and they were one of the teams “kind of” interested in Rudolph. Isaiah Wynn is in the final year of his contract, and Bill loves trading guys who want new contracts.
That said, the rumor is that Bill is going to live or die with Mac Jones… in hopes of “not tanking” for one of the top-tier QBs in the 2023 draft. So, he might not want another QB, nor a receiver. Then again, that could also mean he’s willing to get rid of any offensive player (Wynn) who doesn’t help them “not tank”.
SUMMATION:
Wynn for our R3 makes sense.
Wynn for Sims, Rudolph, and our R4 would be my preference.
I heard that Wynn has been struggling since they decided to move away from power run blocking to a zone blocking scheme. It seems that other than finding a franchise QB, offensive line has become the most difficult unit of a team to put together in today's NFL.
I don't know if the team has any interest, but it seems he can be an effective player if put in the right system.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
steelreserve
What he should do against the Bengals is announce Joe Burrow as the starter, and then everyone will go, "You can't do that, he's on the other team!!" but he'll be like, "too late, I announced it," and then they'll have to spend the whole week preparing for Burrow and they'll be all pissed off.
Then when the game starts, he says "offense, play defense - defense, play offense," and amazingly, that improves the OL.
That's the role of a franchise QB... yelling the obvious at their team.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lEHZJNQ5Y4A
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Don't know why Tomlin isn't just coming out and saying Mitch is the starter, we all know that's happening. The Bengals are probably already prepping for him.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
DuckHodges
Don't know why Tomlin isn't just coming out and saying Mitch is the starter, we all know that's happening. The Bengals are probably already prepping for him.
But we don't all really know... It's assumed. But it was also assumed that Tomlin would take Malik Willis in R1:20. I think there's a small chance that there's some level of uncertainty and Tomlin is giving one final week of practice to decide. What I know is that Tomlin REALLY likes Pickett. A lot! So, I'd say it's 90% Trubisky.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
The best thing I’ve observed happened during the last preseason game. Pickett slung a pass deep over the middle. Incomplete by fingertips. Trubisky and Rudolph exploded off the sideline in anticipation of the big play. Great to see that all 3 are invested in group success not individual achievement.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mojouw
The best thing I’ve observed happened during the last preseason game. Pickett slung a pass deep over the middle. Incomplete by fingertips. Trubisky and Rudolph exploded off the sideline in anticipation of the big play. Great to see that all 3 are invested in group success not individual achievement.
was that the pass that the backup TE couldn't haul in? I remember watching that and saying if that was freiermuth that'd have been a TD
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mojouw
The best thing I’ve observed happened during the last preseason game. Pickett slung a pass deep over the middle. Incomplete by fingertips. Trubisky and Rudolph exploded off the sideline in anticipation of the big play. Great to see that all 3 are invested in group success not individual achievement.
That was good to see for sure!
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
DuckHodges
was that the pass that the backup TE couldn't haul in? I remember watching that and saying if that was freiermuth that'd have been a TD
I think so.
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
DuckHodges
was that the pass that the backup TE couldn't haul in? I remember watching that and saying if that was freiermuth that'd have been a TD
yes sternberger and he was cut
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
Not sure if this has been posted yet but here's a great breakdown of Pickett's two games by Kurt Warner.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4qTeXXOOW-0
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
-
Re: Thread for the QB competition!
CBS is saying Pickett is the #2. It was an error that MR was listed #2 on the depth chart. Sorry if this was already posted.
https://www.cbsnews.com/pittsburgh/n...g-quarterback/