Originally Posted by
steelreserve
Oh, this again.
A better question is, what has Tomlin done above and beyond what you'd expect from any random NFL coach? Nothing. He hasn't let everything come completely unglued and go 4-12, good for him. But he had the HUGE advantage of having one of the best QBs in the league, which you can't say for 95% of the other coaches that have come and gone during his tenure.
Put Tomlin in charge of some team like the Bills or the Buccaneers, and he'd get you your 4-12 record, maybe be one-and-done, and then this whole conversation is stupid. Take any halfway decent coach who isn't in way over his head at the NFL level - say, Tom Coughlin or Jeff Fisher - put him on the Steelers circa 2006, and I'd bet you $100 you'd get the exact same result as Tomlin if not better.
What have I seen from Tomlin? A lot of bluster, a lot of the team being unprepared, almost zero player development except for a few special cases - and some really obvious deficiencies in how the team is put together, which appear to stem not from bad luck or the regular ups and downs of the draft, but from stubbornness and/or just not getting how certain things work.
"You can't use the argument that it's Cowher's players anymore!" Well, what has he done now that it's all his own players? Consistently play .500 ball with an elite QB and a team that everyone thinks is more talented than its record shows. A good coach would have us wrapping up a playoff spot around Thanksgiving and we'd be debating whether resting your starters too much is the right move or not. Great coaches take players like we have and do things like invent new offensive schemes around them. What are we doing? Mucking around in pigshit and struggling to make the playoffs one year out of four. One of the best 6 or 7 coaches in the league - get the fuck out of here.