Add one player from anywhere in the NFL to the Steelers current roster for just this season,Who is it?

[polamalubeast]

1136982791776821250

Khalil Mack would be my choice.

[JimHarbaugh'ssoakedtissue]

AB.

[Mojouw]

Derwin James

[Butch]

AB.

LOL Are you an average NFL fan?

[86WARD]

AJ Bouye or Jalen Ramsey

[86WARD]

AB.

Lol. Boomin!

[Born2Steel]

Baker Mayfield.

[polamalubeast]

Baker Mayfield.

The question is just for this season!

[st33lersguy]

Khalil mack, bud Dupree is not the answer across tj watt

[tube517]

Is Jon Kuhn still active?

[Born2Steel]

The question is just for this season!

That's funny! :rofl2:

[steelreserve]

Tom Brady. Sits on bench inactive all year. Patriots have no quarterback, miss playoffs. We cakewalk to a bye; two hands of blackjack to make the Super Bowl.

[st33lersguy]

Tom Brady. Sits on bench inactive all year. Patriots have no quarterback, miss playoffs. We cakewalk to a bye; two hands of blackjack to make the Super Bowl.

With no QB they finish 8-8, maybe 9-7, more than enough to win that pathetic excuse of a division

[JimHarbaugh'ssoakedtissue]

Tom Brady. Sits on bench inactive all year. Patriots have no quarterback, miss playoffs. We cakewalk to a bye; two hands of blackjack to make the Super Bowl. Would be cool to see if Tomlin keeps Dobbs in instead of Brady cause of the flow of the game!

[hawaiiansteeler]

Would be cool to see if Tomlin keeps Dobbs in instead of Brady cause of the flow of the game!

especially when Dobbs is playing so well :rolleyes:

[BlackAndGold]

Derwin James or Eddie Jackson at safety.

Having the GOAT Tom Brady starting at QB would be great also.

[86WARD]

Tom Brady. Sits on bench inactive all year. Patriots have no quarterback, miss playoffs. We cakewalk to a bye; two hands of blackjack to make the Super Bowl.

Brady would just whine his way off the roster, genius fandom of Colbert and Tomlin would outright release him and Brady would take a 1-8 Patriots team to an 8-8 division title and playoff birth...if they play Pittsburgh in the playoffs, they win Super Bowl #7...lol

[teegre]

Aaron Donald is hands down the most disruptive player in the NFL.

Does se he fit in our 3-4? Eh, maybe. I’d play him at DE, and move Cam Heyward to NT (where Cam has played before). That said... our D-line is already good. While Donald would make them insanely good, we have other areas of bigger need.

Khalil Mack and Derwin James are playmakers. Period. (Plus, we have needs at both positions.)

SUMMATION:
Spin the wheel... and, give me any of those three.

[teegre]

The offense is pretty set, but I’d love to have a year where the interior of the O-line had Quenton Nelson, Pouncey, and DeCastro. #chills

George Kittle would be a good add, as well.

But, honestly, while we have some good, young talent at RT, we would secure the right side (biggest question mark) with Mike McGlinchey.

[munchy]

tom brady...........
even with a stud defender, you still have coaches calling a soft defense or having them drop into coverage or having a smart HC scheme around that player
with brady, you know that he is going to call the right play and make the correct read. the guy has excelled with talent far less than whats on our current roster

[Mojouw]

Ryan Shazier?

Davis, Edmunds, Shazier, and Bush right down the middle of the defense? I don't know what it would look like, but that would be a great deal of "freak" level athleticism in a concentrated area of the field.

[Rotorhead]

Mack

[GoSlash27]

I figure we have all the talent we need on offense and defense, so I'll go with Justin Tucker.

[Steeldude]

Tom Brady. Sits on bench inactive all year. Patriots have no quarterback, miss playoffs. We cakewalk to a bye; two hands of blackjack to make the Super Bowl.

Then again, Belichick has shown he can still have the Patriots playing well with another QB.

Bench BR and start Brady to improve the blackjack hands : )

[GoSlash27]

Then again, Belichick has shown he can still have the Patriots playing well with another QB.

Bench BR and start Brady to improve the blackjack hands : )

Brady isn't physically tough enough to play AFCN ball.

[munchy]

Brady isn't physically tough enough to play AFCN ball.


really. when was the last time the afcn had a physical defense?

[polamalubeast]

really. when was the last time the afcn had a physical defense?

Brady was not very good against the Ravens between 2009 to 2012, especially in the playoffs.

[Mojouw]

Brady was not very good against the Ravens between 2009 to 2012, especially in the playoffs.

I feel like a defense anchored by multiple HOF players and Ed Reed (he belongs in the hall of the just unbelievable or something) might have had something to do with that. I don't care how tough you are or are not, when Suggs and Lewis are moving you off your spot and you are throwing into a secondary anchored by Ed Reed, you are going to struggle a bit.

[DesertSteel]

Aaron Donald. He can’t be stopped.

[polamalubeast]

I feel like a defense anchored by multiple HOF players and Ed Reed (he belongs in the hall of the just unbelievable or something) might have had something to do with that. I don't care how tough you are or are not, when Suggs and Lewis are moving you off your spot and you are throwing into a secondary anchored by Ed Reed, you are going to struggle a bit.

And even if his players were old at this time (Ray Lewis and Ed Reed) they were very smart and they always had a great game plan.

[JimHarbaugh'ssoakedtissue]

Aaron Donald. He can’t be stopped. The Zebra's can if they want and didn't it to Harrison.

[teegre]

I figure we have all the talent we need on offense and defense, so I'll go with Justin Tucker.

Great answer!!! :nod: Last season, we win two more games straight-up (and possibly a third) if we simply make two (three?) freakin’ FGs!!!

[Dwinsgames]

Von Miller .....

put him on the field in place of Dupree and let him and TJ pin their ears back down after down ....

if a QB has no time to throw I could play Corner and the team be successful ( since I broke my leg in 3 places running is not something I can do ) ........

[EzraTank]

Can I pick Belichick as coach instead? That way he could fire all of Tomlin's assistants.

[st33lersguy]

Von Miller .....

put him on the field in place of Dupree and let him and TJ pin their ears back down after down ....

if a QB has no time to throw I could play Corner and the team be successful ( since I broke my leg in 3 places running is not something I can do ) ........

I was strongly considering him, but went with Mack cause he is 2 years younger

[JnK]

I'd say Brady for one reason only. I want all of the Boston fans to see him dress in Black and Gold for one season just to drive them insane.

[steelreserve]

All these people saying Tom Brady - ugh. What I suggested was merely to put him on the roster and deactivate him so the Patriots would be screwed over. Then release him 5 minutes before the kickoff of the Super Bowl so he doesn't "win" another title.

I would rather be in the front row of the crowd at the Nathan's hot dog eating contest, and then have Joey Chestnut eat 70 hot dogs and throw up on me, and the throw-up goes in my mouth and I swallow it, than ever see Tom Brady actually play a down for the Steelers.

Unless MAYBE it was one of those things where the linemen get out of the way and let him get injured. But even then, it would be a barfy sight.

[munchy]

I feel like a defense anchored by multiple HOF players and Ed Reed (he belongs in the hall of the just unbelievable or something) might have had something to do with that. I don't care how tough you are or are not, when Suggs and Lewis are moving you off your spot and you are throwing into a secondary anchored by Ed Reed, you are going to struggle a bit.

agreed. even if we say that defense was tough, 3 years doesnt make the entire afcn physical

[Dwinsgames]

I was strongly considering him, but went with Mack cause he is 2 years younger

since the question posed a " 1 year only " pre qualifier those 2 years didn't matter to me ... but the reality its a 1A) 1B) proposition I don't think between the 2 of them there is a wrong choice

[vasteeler]

Brady would have been killed with the offensive line we had several years ago.

Edit: and then I noticed you're referring to this season only:doh2:

[munchy]

Brady would have been killed with the offensive line we had several years ago.

Edit: and then I noticed you're referring to this season only:doh2:


brady would have adapted and got rid of the ball quickly...like he always does

[DesertSteel]

All these people saying Tom Brady - ugh. What I suggested was merely to put him on the roster and deactivate him so the Patriots would be screwed over. Then release him 5 minutes before the kickoff of the Super Bowl so he doesn't "win" another title.

I would rather be in the front row of the crowd at the Nathan's hot dog eating contest, and then have Joey Chestnut eat 70 hot dogs and throw up on me, and the throw-up goes in my mouth and I swallow it, than ever see Tom Brady actually play a down for the Steelers.

Unless MAYBE it was one of those things where the linemen get out of the way and let him get injured. But even then, it would be a barfy sight.
Does he send the rent checks directly to you for that space in your mind?

[steelreserve]

Does he send the rent checks directly to you for that space in your mind?

I thought to be in your mind, someone was supposed to be an opponent or rival, not just some random football player that you think is a piece of shit.

[vasteeler]

brady would have adapted and got rid of the ball quickly...like he always does

Please ... not when your OC calls for every receiver to go deep.

[polamalubeast]

brady would have adapted and got rid of the ball quickly...like he always does

Maybe not

1131915634365878272

[Devilsdancefloor]

Luke Kuechly

[st33lersguy]

I'd say Brady for one reason only. I want all of the Boston fans to see him dress in Black and Gold for one season just to drive them insane.

They may just convert to Steelers fans. Many are bandwagon jumpers who will jump ship when the Pat's become irrelevant again after Brady and bellichick are gone anyway

[zulater]

I figure we have all the talent we need on offense and defense, so I'll go with Justin Tucker.


Good one. It's between him and Aaron Donald for me. Both are generational type players. Donald might be the most fun player to watch in the league. But in the end I'll go Tucker. Every time you cross midfield you're in scoring range with him.

[Six Rings]

Tom Brady. Sits on bench inactive all year. Patriots have no quarterback, miss playoffs. We cakewalk to a bye; two hands of blackjack to make the Super Bowl.

Perfect. Thread closed as far as I'm concerned.

[DesertSteel]

I thought to be in your mind, someone was supposed to be an opponent or rival, not just some random football player that you think is a piece of shit.
Denial is one way to go.