Biggest Steelers killer (Tom Brady or Steve McNair)

[polamalubeast]

Who is the biggest steelers killer between the two?


Steve McNair finished his career with a record of 12-5 against the steelers.And two to his 5 losses was with the 5-11 Titans in 2005 and the 5-11 Ravens in 2007.When Mcnair had a good team, he almost always won against the steelers.

Tom Brady is 6-1 against the Steelers, and since 2004 three of the worst performences the Steelers defense was against the Patriots and Brady. The Steelers have given 41 points in playoff in 2004,
in 2007, he had 399 yards and last year the Steelers have given 39 points.Brady has a QB rating of 104.3 against the Steelers in his career.


Who is the biggest steelers killer between the two?

[fansince'76]

I still say McNair as we played him much more often.

[Chidi29]

I still say McNair as we played him much more often.

And were divisonal opponents for awhile.

[suitanim]

C) Kent Graham

[Chidi29]

C) Kent Graham

:chuckle:

[Psycho Ward 86]

brady hands down...

[steeldevil]

Otto Graham went 11-1 against us in 6 seasons....

Of course a lot of that probably had to do with the Browns being amazing in that period and the Steelers being bad to below average.

[tube517]

Otto Graham went 11-1 against us in 6 seasons....


C) Kent Graham

Related??? :chuckle:

[steelerdude15]

Can Neil O'Donnell be in this? :lol:

[GBMelBlount]

Otto Graham went 11-1 against us in 6 seasons....



Automatic Otto....nice find. :thumbsup:

[steelreserve]

I don't think I can vote for being afraid of a dead guy.

Patriots suck and Tom Brady is gay.

[O'Malley]

I still say McNair as we played him much more often.

He haunts us to the day.... Too soon...:behindsofa:

[zulater]

Brady by a lot. Not only does he beat us, he beats us like a drum, does it in huge games (two AFC championships), and does it in Pittsburgh as easy as if it was in Gillette.

I know McNair had some great games against us, but my memory seems to be that we won our share, particularly in Pgh. and that most of the losses went down to the gun.

[BlastFurnace]

Brady. The Steelers still beat McNair 5 times. Other than the Halloween game, every game against Brady has been a beatdown. I'd rather play McNair any day of the week than Brady.

[HometownGal]

I go with McNair. Dude always gave us fits and we played against him back when football was a man's game. Never saw McNair whine or look to the ref for a flag when he was sacked or even breathed upon. A$$ Chin is babied by the refs and has come to expect being coddled. McNair took his lumps, got right back up and continued to give us fits. One of the toughest SOB's to play the game. :rip:

[7SteelGal43]

http://youtu.be/nesIKo0BHEs

[86WARD]

Brady. He did it in bigger games against better Steelers teams.